How it Works

For Teams

For Leaders

Data

Media

About

Book a Call

How much should I tell my team when things are uncertain?

Nov 17, 2026

Photo accompanying the Groops newsletter on communicating honestly with teams during uncertainty.


“Honesty is the first chapter in the book of wisdom.”

— Thomas Jefferson, letter to Nathaniel Macon, 1819

Yesterday, Sergio Lopez Ferrero, Global CEO of Omnicom Production, joined my Motivation class, where we focus on what drives human behavior (at work). It was his second visit, and he was also a guest on The Psychology of Work podcast earlier this year. Sergio is bringing more than 100 production companies across dozens of countries into one global organization, while AI is changing how creative work gets made. It’s all happening in public, and it involves hard decisions that affect people’s jobs and lives.

When Sergio speaks, I find myself mapping what he says against the team and organizational psychology frameworks I’ve studied, and against what I’ve learned from working with companies going through change. He adds color to the constructs I know.

But when he talked about the difference between honesty and transparency, I felt a little cognitive dissonance. It was that “I don’t know this yet, tell me more” feeling, like an itch I wanted to scratch.

The way Sergio described it, honesty means you don’t tell people things that aren’t true. Transparency, taken all the way, means telling people everything you know. You owe your team honesty, but you can’t always give them full transparency. What you can do is be truthful about what you can and can’t say.

I think about honesty a lot. In my earlier days, I believed that more honesty meant deeper intimacy in basically every part of my life, not just at work. What I’ve come to learn is that you don’t have to tell everybody everything at all times. Often, the urge to share everything is more of an anxious response than a helpful one, and what matters most is protecting the shared goals and the relationship. In psychology, we often ask ourselves a simple question before we say anything sensitive. For what purpose am I sharing this?

One of my students shared that the best manager she ever had was during a huge reorg. Her manager didn’t know more than anyone else, and she never promised it would all be fine. She was honest about what she couldn’t say, and the team trusted her more because of it.

If you’re scaling a company, you know this moment. Maybe you’re restructuring, someone senior is leaving, a deal or a round hasn’t closed, or you’re not sure yet what next quarter looks like. Your team can feel that something is going on, and you can’t tell them everything yet. So you’re stuck wondering, do I say something now, or wait until I know more?

There’s research on why waiting in silence is so hard on people. In a study at University College London, people who had a 50% chance of getting a mild electric shock were more stressed than people who knew for sure they would get one (de Berker et al., 2016).

It was a lab study, not a workplace one, but anyone who has been through a reorg knows the feeling. When people don’t have information, they assume the worst, and on a distributed team that happens in side conversations and DMs you never see.

That’s also why false reassurance backfires. “Nothing to worry about” might calm things down for a day, but if it turns out to be wrong, people stop believing what you say next.

What to say when you can’t say everything

  1. Before you share anything, ask yourself, for what purpose am I sharing this?

  2. Tell people what you know right now.

  3. Tell them what you don’t know yet, and what you can’t share and why.

  4. Tell them when they’ll hear from you next, and then follow through, even if nothing has changed.

That last one matters most. Checking in when you said you would, especially when there’s nothing new, is how people learn they can trust you while things are still uncertain.

At Groops, we think of cohesion as connection plus alignment, and uncertainty puts pressure on both at the same time. How you communicate when you can’t say everything has a big impact on whether your team holds together. And trust is something you can measure, not just hope for.

Bobbi

P.S. If you’re leading a growing team through uncertainty, whether that’s a reorg, a key departure, or rapid growth, this is exactly what we’re working on with our founding design partners. We’re bringing on a small group of companies, and each cohort gets better pricing than the next.

Reply to this email and I’ll send you a demo video to watch on your own time, or book a time to meet with us below to talk about becoming a design partner.

Book time to meet with us


References

de Berker, A. O., Rutledge, R. B., Mathys, C., Marshall, L., Cross, G. F., Dolan, R. J., & Bestmann, S. (2016). Computations of uncertainty mediate acute stress responses in humans. Nature Communications, 7, 10996. https://doi.org/10.1038/ncomms10996

Get the next newsletter in your inbox.

Practical organizational psychology delivered to your inbox every other week.

Get the next newsletter in your inbox.

Practical organizational psychology delivered to your inbox every other week.

Get the next newsletter in your inbox.

Practical organizational psychology delivered to your inbox every other week.

Groops for Teams and Leaders

Ready to unlock your team’s potential?

Team and one-on-one coaching with Groop Guides, available 24/7.

Free Quiz

Groops for Teams and Leaders

Ready to unlock your team’s potential?

Team and one-on-one coaching with Groop Guides, available 24/7.

Free Quiz

Groops for Teams and Leaders

Ready to unlock your team’s potential?

Team and one-on-one coaching with Groop Guides, available 24/7.

Free Quiz